The World of Agusan Manobo Music
Sunday, August 17, 2008
Signs of recognition: myth of reciprocity
This is the myth that forms the basis of Agusan Manobo spirit-possession ritual. Which came first--myth or ritual--is an intellectual question, but the two are absolutely inseparable.
In this simple story with a repetitive symmetry in the episodes, the Manobo person (in the name of Ujahay) is positioned between two existential domains, “vertical and horizontal”: (1) death or hunger (see event labelled 1 above) and life or joy (event labelled 6) and (2) between nature and society. The person’s relationship in nature and society is gendered, with interesting structural inversions and reversibility of effects. What the person (Ujahay) is to receive via a medium (his wife) from his brother (=the person’s katungod or related self) is what that person (Ujahay) is to receive from another medium (the female spirit). The rupture of interpersonal relations in the story, the non-recognition of the person’s rights to receive, give, and share is the condition for the expression of pity, which comes about almost automatically or miraculously in the image of a spirit. What divisions society brings to interpersonal relationships (as the brothers are both married and hence are, in principle, independent) is what nature mysteriously heals. The appearance of the spirit compensates for the ruptures in human relationship; the spirit pities; it balances the loss of resonance that proper human conduct must necessarily have.
The didactic content of the myth rings with clarion tones. The moral value of the story is mimetically represented in curing rites. In fact, a curing ritual is like a mise-en-scene of the basic value of the Gift, which particularly functions as a sign of recognition. The symbolic value of the Gift in Manobo culture is therefore different from Mauss’s concept of Gift, which demands a return. In Manobo culture, the Gift essentially indicates an interpersonal relationship--a presence of self to a related other--that do not co-erce a countergift. In the story, Ujahay clearly and merely demanded the rights for his presences to be recognized by a related Other, his brother.